4 Comments
User's avatar
Gillian Oh's avatar

Wouldn’t the reason B is incorrect as minor sixth in an Eb key, versus Cb, be that they function differently — Cb implying a lead downward (diminution) and B a lead upward (augmentation)?

Expand full comment
Svetoslav's avatar

I think you're mistaking the intervals with the note names. The flat 6, i.e. b6, or B/Cb in this case, is just an interval a minor sixth from the root, Eb.

The name of the note does not in any way indicate its function. C natural is the flat 3rd in the key of A minor, for example. F natural is the b6 in that same key.

B/Cb are called enharmonic equivalents in modern Western theory, even though it wasn't always the case.

Expand full comment
Gillian Oh's avatar

Is C the sharp two in A though? I think most would specify that as B#, C’s enharmonic equivalent.

Expand full comment
Svetoslav's avatar

Not really, it's the flat 3. Which is the same note, but I don't think anyone uses #2. #9, sure, but #2 I haven't seen or heard of. In any case, it's not the interval that determines which enharmonic equivalent to use. And Cb and B# are very rarely used in any case, just like E#, Fb, F##, etc. Yeah, I don't like playing in C#.

Expand full comment